The New York Knicks are confronting a significant challenge in retaining Isaiah Hartenstein as he enters free agency. Hartenstein, who joined the Knicks due to a quirk in the collective bargaining agreement, has become an indispensable part of the team’s identity. Despite his journey through multiple teams—Rockets, Nuggets, and Cavaliers—Hartenstein’s breakout season came with the Los Angeles Clippers, where he excelled as a rim protector behind Ivica Zubac. However, contractual limitations prevented the Clippers from retaining him, leading him to the Knicks.
Isaiah Hartenstein Value and Contractual Challenges
Hartenstein’s tenure with the Clippers was hindered by the limited contractual options available due to his low market value at the time. The Clippers could only offer him a modest raise or use their taxpayer mid-level exception, which they allocated to John Wall instead. Consequently, the Knicks seized the opportunity to sign him with their mid-level exception.
In New York, Hartenstein’s rim protection and offensive rebounding have been pivotal. His contributions extend beyond defense; his floaters, screening, and passing have made him an offensive asset. This made Hartenstein one of the best free-agent bargains for the Knicks.
The Bird Rights Dilemma
The Knicks, like the Clippers before them, face a significant hurdle in keeping Hartenstein due to the Bird Rights mechanism. If Hartenstein had been able to secure a three-year deal initially, the Knicks could re-sign him in 2025 with full Bird Rights, allowing for a more flexible salary offer. However, with only a two-year deal in place, the Knicks possess only Early Bird Rights, limiting their offer to 175% of his previous salary, approximately $16.2 million next season.
Market Competition and Potential Suitors
At 26 years old, Hartenstein is still on an upward trajectory. While non-shooting centers often struggle to secure lucrative contracts, Hartenstein’s performance warrants a competitive salary. Comparisons to overpaid centers like Zach Collins, Jusuf Nurkic, and Nikola Vucevic will undoubtedly influence his contract negotiations.
Several teams could theoretically pursue Hartenstein. Eight teams could create significant cap space: Pistons, 76ers, Jazz, Thunder, Magic, Spurs, Hornets, and Raptors. However, many of these teams either have established centers or other priorities, narrowing the competition to potentially the Thunder and Spurs.
The Thunder, with substantial cap space, might offer a short-term, high-salary deal. This would provide Hartenstein with financial security and the opportunity to re-enter free agency while still in his prime. The Spurs, more flexible with their lineup and willing to play Victor Wembanyama at power forward, could also be a potential fit.
Knicks’ Offer and Isaiah Hartenstein Decision
If a lucrative deal does not materialize elsewhere, the Knicks are likely to offer Hartenstein the maximum allowable under Early Bird Rights, potentially around $72.5 million over four years. Alternatively, Hartenstein might opt for a shorter-term deal with a player option, allowing him to leverage full Bird Rights for a more lucrative contract next summer.
Hartenstein, having just completed his first non-minimum NBA contract may prioritize financial security. However, his value to the Knicks is evident, as demonstrated in the postseason. The Knicks’ reliance on him, particularly given Mitchell Robinson’s injury history and Tom Thibodeau’s coaching style, underscores the importance of retaining Hartenstein. Despite the challenges, both parties recognize the value he brings, making it crucial for the Knicks to navigate this uphill battle successfully.
Comments